Search Results
Back to JTS Torah Online's Main pageFrom Symposium to Seder: How The Rabbinic Adoption of Roman Party Conventions Became Our Passover Seder
Apr 15, 2024 By Robert Harris | Public Event video | Video Lecture | Pesah
In the years following the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, Jewish observance of Passover underwent a seismic shift. In lieu of the now impossible sacrificial Temple ritual, the rabbis adopted the Roman symposium in order to create a new type of festival meal, one that was rooted in new rituals and intellectual discourse. Together we explore what led to the rabbinic decision to conduct the Seder in this way, rather than opting for a different way to commemorate Passover, such as instructing the Jewish people to perform the sacrifice in their homes. We also examine some of the questions and answers in the Haggadah which are central features of the Roman symposium and core to our Haggadah.
Read MoreThe People Step Up
Mar 8, 2024 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Shabbat Shekalim | Vayak-hel
By this point in the Book of Exodus, the story outlines are probably familiar: the people—having been redeemed from Egypt and covenanted with God on Mt. Sinai, and having already sinned a terrible sin by building the Golden Calf—respond to God’s detailed instructions to build a Tabernacle by donating so generously that the collection of the material with which to construct the sanctuary has to be stopped midway, even as the people are still in the process of donating.
Read MoreDid Korah Get a Bum Rap?
Jun 23, 2023 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Korah
The memory of Huey Long, and the continued concern over the role of demagoguery in American politics, comes to mind this week because we see a prime example of it in Parashat Korah—the figure of Korah himself. (The character of Dathan, played by Edgar G. Robinson, in The Ten Commandments, was essentially based on Korah). Korah was long vilified by the Rabbinic Sages, and of course the Torah itself condemns him as the paradigmatic rebel against the divinely sanctioned leadership of Moses and Aaron.
Read MoreThe Meaning of Aaron’s Holy Garments
Mar 3, 2023 By Robert Harris | Shabbat Zakhor | Tetzavveh
In this commentary, I would like to focus on some of the vestments of Aaron that he wore in his capacity as kohen gadol (High Priest). At the beginning of Exodus 28, the Torah commands that the Israelites who are skilled artisans should prepare a specific list of items for Aaron and the priests to wear. These include the breastpiece, ephod, robe, fringed tunic, headdress, and sash.
Read MoreWhy God Needs a Dwelling Place
Feb 8, 2019 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Terumah
Recent portions of the Torah have dealt with the arrival of the Israelites at Mount Sinai; the great theophany of God, in which God spoke the Ten Words, or Decalogue; the revelation of the Book of the Covenant, containing the first extended legal section of the Torah; and the covenantal ceremony sealing the everlasting special relationship between God and the people of Israel (Exod. 19–24). Our portion this week turns to the subject of proper worship of God (a subject with which the Torah will be concerned formally for the next eight portions), and opens with a command from God that Moses organize the people to build God a sanctuary in the wilderness: “And the Lord spoke to Moses, saying: ‘Speak to the Israelites that they may take for me a contribution; from everyone whose heart so moves him, take my contribution . . . and let them make me a sanctuary, that I may dwell among them’” (Exod. 25:1–2,8).
Read MoreExodus 18: The Proverbial Visit of the In-Laws
Jan 15, 2014 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Yitro
“Come and listen to my story ’bout a man named . . . Jethro!”
Read MoreThe Fruits of Close Reading
Sep 16, 2013 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Sukkot
“In order that future generations may know that I made the Israelite people live in booths when I brought them out of the land of Egypt” (Lev. 23:43).
Read MoreWho Is Getting Stoned?
May 29, 2013 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Shelah Lekha
Among other subjects, the parashah narrates the story of the spies, one from each tribe, whom Moses sends to scout out the Land. Specifically, let us join the narrative at the point that Joshua and Caleb (the two good or “heroic” spies) attempt to encourage the community—largely ineffectively—after the People express their fears that any effort to conquer the Promised Land will not be successful.
Read More“Truthiness” in the Bible
Feb 7, 2013 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
What the Bible Means, What it Meant, and Why the Difference Matters: A recorded live stream lunch and learn
“He Taught Him a Tree” (?!)
Jan 23, 2013 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Beshallah
This week’s parashah contains some of the most memorable narratives in the entire Torah: the splitting of the Reed Sea, the miracle of the manna, the battle with Amalek. In the midst of all these narratives comes a pithily told “little tale.”
Read More“Alas, Poor Yorick”: A Grave Affair
Aug 25, 2012 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Shofetim
I wish to call your attention specifically to the Torah’s prohibition of “inquiring of the dead.” Rashi seems to adumbrate Shakespeare, when he includes “one who asks questions of a skull” among the possible actions that would represent a violation of the biblical commandment. But the Torah is not imagining a philosophical discourse about life when it prohibits “inquiring of the dead,” but rather, in what is likely its original context, necromancy.
Read MoreI Stayed with Laban
Dec 10, 2011 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Vayishlah
The opening verses of this week’s parashah recount Jacob’s decision, upon returning home after 20 years of “living abroad,” to get in touch with his brother, Esau. You may remember that they—ahem!—had not parted on the best of terms (see Gen. 25:27-34 and especially Gen. 27:1-41 for the gritty details). At the beginning of the parashah, it is not yet clear to what extent Jacob is motivated by fear, by friendliness, by craftiness—or by some combination of these and potentially other concerns.
Read MoreShabbat in the Bible – and Not in the Bible Part 1
Oct 30, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
A surprising look at the description of Shabbat in the Hebrew Bible
Part one of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Shabbat in the Bible – and Not in the Bible Part 2
Oct 29, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
A surprising look at the description of Shabbat in the Hebrew Bible
Part two of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Shabbat: Mountains Hanging by a Thread
Oct 28, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
Shabbat in Midrash and Talmud
Part three of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Hitchcock and the Sages: The 39 Steps
Oct 27, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
Part four of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Read MoreYou Are One and Your Name Is One
Oct 26, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
Part five of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Read MoreMizmor Shir Leyom HaShabbat: Shabbat in Liturgy and Song
Oct 25, 2010 By Robert Harris | Video Lecture
Part six of the six-part series, “Shabbat: From Here to Eternity”
Read MoreTeach Us to Number, O God!
May 15, 2010 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Bemidbar
Our Torah portion this week begins the fourth book of the Torah (see? I’m numbering already!), B’midbar. This Hebrew name of the book comes from one of the first significant words in the book, and means “in the wilderness of . . . ” (see below). But in rabbinic antiquity, another name of the book circulated, and that was humash (orsefer) Ha-piqqudim, which essentially means “Book of Counting” (see, e.g., Mishnah Yoma 7:1). This name corresponds to the ancient Jewish Greek version, Arithmoi, which was rendered by the Latin Vulgate Numeri, from which comes our current English title, “Numbers.
Read MoreThe Meaning of Aaron’s Holy Garments
Feb 27, 2010 By Robert Harris | Commentary | Tetzavveh
The Torah portion of T’tzavveh continues God’s instructions to the Israelites for building the Tabernacle in the Wilderness—the central concern of the previous week’s Torah portion (T’rumah) and the next three portions as well (Ki Tissa, Va-yakhel, and P’kudei). Altogether, the Tabernacle and its accoutrements are the most prominent subject matter of the entire last section of the book of Exodus, comprising chapters 25 through 40. These portions cover many details, the precise explanation for many of which remains somewhat uncertain to this very day.
Read MoreSUBSCRIBE TO TORAH FROM JTS
Our regular commentaries and videos are a great way to stay intellectually and spiritually engaged with Jewish thought and wisdom.